|Posted: 2/4/2013 3:47:08 PM|
I'm curious about the benefit of the size of the cameo over the smaller portrait. How often would the average scrapper need the larger size? I like the smaller size (since I have limited scrap space & enjoy crops), not to mention the lower price. But I'd certainly rather save longer for the cameo than end up regretting a smaller machine. Thanks for your thoughts, peas!
Made 5000, now what?
|Posted: 2/4/2013 4:05:24 PM|
I haven't bought either machine yet but my thought process is that the only reason I would need a Cameo is when I want to cut out the cute folding boxes and 3D items they release in the store. Sometimes to get those at an appropriate size you do need the full 12x12 size available.
But for my actual scrapbooking, I would never need the 12x12 capability. When I decide to buy I will get the Cameo unless there's a big price gap between the two machines.
1 Pea, 2 Pea, Red Pea, Blue Pea
Loc: Seattle, WA, USA
|Posted: 2/4/2013 4:15:43 PM|
I've had the Silhouette SD for 2 years and have never needed the wider size. The only annoying thing is that I have to cut down 12x12 paper before running it through the machine.
Note that it's just the width that you're limited - you can cut really long things still, even with the narrower width.
So if you're looking for an even better deal, you may want to look for a gently used Silhouette SD. I've seen them for around $120.
Ancient Ancestor of Pea
|Posted: 2/4/2013 4:35:18 PM|
I have the cameo and I like that I don't have to cut my paper down. I can also fit more stuff I need to cut out on one sheet with the 12x12. I also like the ability to cut 12x12 borders.
Loc: Houston, TX
|Posted: 2/4/2013 4:35:24 PM|
I bought the larger one but I make locker decorations for the kid's teams every year and really appreciate the larger size when I do those. I also use the bigger size for sports party decorations for the MS and HS. So.. it all depends on what you are going to use it for. I rarely use the larger size for scrapbooking.
Mom of Carly (16) and Nathan (14)
Loc: NorthCentral PA
|Posted: 2/4/2013 7:45:03 PM|
I had my SD for YEARS, and used it just for scrapping. Then, I bought my Cameo, thinking it would just be for scrapping too...
Once I saw what it could do, I changed my mind quick. With the 12x12 size I can make boxes, bags, holiday decorations...my favorites are the 3d haunted house and the 9 inch hat box-which I use when I'm gifting a cake.
If you want to limit youself and KNOW that you won't ever make any of the 3d stuff, you'll be fine wtih the Portrait. However, once you start finding all of the cool things you can do with the Cameo, you might change your mind.
Loc: Scarsdale, NY
|Posted: 2/4/2013 8:00:30 PM|
I recently purchased the portrait and love that I chose the smaller size....I already have the cricut expression though for larger items like schoolprojects with the kids on posterboard, but just for my PL and card amking...I don't think I'll ever need the larger sizes....hope this helps....am totally LOVING this machine!,! Sooooo small and compact!
Loc: Rolla, Missouri
|Posted: 2/4/2013 9:51:51 PM|
Love seeing all the different opinions! Thanks everyone!
PEAring through my camera lens
|Posted: 2/5/2013 6:16:40 AM|
While my machine is a Gazelle rather than a Cameo, it's somewhat similar, and it will cut the same size. I also have a Wishblade, which is a "sister" machine to the Silhouette. I had my Wishblade first.
I prefer using a larger machine. I like to make the large shaped backgrounds for my 12x12 pages. I like to make 3D projects. I can put more images for cutting at once on the mat, and position the paper/cardstock in such a way that multiple colors can be cut at the same time. I can do more with the bigger machine, so for me, it has been well worth it.
Yes, the Cameo is going to be a bit bigger, but we're only talking a few inches wider than the smaller machine. It's not that much. The price is a bit more, but if you want the added capability, I think it's worth the difference in price.
If you scrap 12x12, you are a little bit limited by the smaller machine. I scrapped for years with my
Wishblade and loved the machine, but I frequently wished I could cut wider than my machine allowed. Once I got the Gazelle, my poor Wishblade has been gathering dust. I kept it because I have literally thousands of designs for it, but the bigger machine meets my needs better.
Every crafter has different needs and wants. Only you can figure out if you will want the bigger machine or be happy with the smaller one, but a lot of people who scrap 12x12 and make 3D projects are happier with a machine that cuts up to 12 inches wide.
|My Scrapn' Blog
Photographers are violent people. First they frame you, then they shoot you, then they hang you on the wall; but if you're real good, they will scrapbook you!
Loc: New York City
Loc: somewhere over the rainbow
|Posted: 2/5/2013 11:17:32 AM|I have had a Silhouette SD for years and so far I haven't had a need for a larger size. I still want to eventually upgrade to the cameo but I can't actually explain why.
|Posted: 2/5/2013 11:19:57 AM|
Thanks for asking this question and for all the great replies. I've been pondering this myself. I'm currently a cricut expression user, but find I don't use it all that much & get frustrated with it easily. Since I mostly scrap on a small scale, mini books & divided page protectors, I have been considering the Portrait. I don't have a lot of space, hence having to "get out" the expression. Hoping the Portrait is something that could fit more easily on desk with computer. Still deciding if I really "need" it tho...
|Posted: 2/5/2013 3:20:42 PM|If you decide to get the Portrait, here is info on the Valentine's Day Portrait bundle and coupon code. I have a Cameo, but I mostly like to do 3D projects, cards, boxes, etc.
Silhouette Valentine's Day Sale and Code